Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This page contains affiliate links; if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.
Half-Sheet Pans Compared: Aluminum vs. Nonstick vs. Stainless
If you bake cookies by the dozen in December, the half-sheet pan is the one piece of bakeware you'll use most. America's Test Kitchen calls it the most useful all-purpose size and suggests having at least one, ideally two. The choices come down to three materials, and the trade-offs are clearer than the marketing makes them sound.
The short answer
- Most bakers: a bare aluminum half sheet, such as the Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet. It's the top pick at America's Test Kitchen, Bon Appétit and Wirecutter. Line it with parchment for cookies.
- If easy release and cleanup matter most: a nonstick aluminized-steel pan such as the USA Pan Half Sheet. Keep it at or below 450°F and away from metal utensils.
- If you often roast tomatoes, citrus or vinegar-heavy dishes: a clad stainless-steel half sheet. It's heavier and much more expensive, but America's Test Kitchen notes it doesn't react with acids the way bare aluminum can.
What "half sheet" actually means
A half sheet is usually listed as about 18 by 13 inches. That's the outside of the pan. America's Test Kitchen points out that the flat cooking surface of most aluminum half sheets is closer to 16½ by 11½ inches, and that's the size most of their recipes assume. Full sheets are for commercial ovens and won't fit a home oven. Quarter sheets (about half the area) are handy for toasting nuts or a small batch of cookies.
Sizes vary a little by brand, and makers measure them differently: Nordic Ware lists interior dimensions, while USA Pan lists a "baking surface." If you want a wire rack or lid to fit snugly, buy one made for that pan's size. America's Test Kitchen found that oversize or squarer pans (several stainless models among them) don't take a standard rack.
Side by side
| Bare aluminum | Nonstick aluminized steel | Clad stainless steel | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Example | Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet (43100) | USA Pan Half Sheet, nonstick (1050HS-1) | Williams Sonoma Thermo-Clad Half Sheet |
| Weight (maker or ATK) | 1.6 lb (Nordic Ware) | Heavier than aluminum; ATK weighed USA Pan's bare version at 2.9 lb | 4.3 lb (ATK) |
| Heat limit | No coating to protect; ATK uses aluminum sheets for broiling | 450°F maximum (USA Pan); ATK says don't put nonstick under the broiler | Safe at high heat (ATK) |
| Sticking | Food sticks unless greased or lined (Wirecutter) | Silicone-based Americoat release coating (USA Pan) | Grease or line, like aluminum |
| Acidic foods | Can react with tomatoes or vinegar (ATK) | Coated surface | Non-reactive (ATK) |
| Dishwasher | No; detergent discolors aluminum (ATK) | No; hand wash (USA Pan) | Hand wash recommended (ATK) |
| Warping in published tests | Resisted warping best in ATK, Bon Appétit and Prudent Reviews tests | Warped in Prudent Reviews' and The Spruce Eats' tests; ATK's bare version warped slightly and recovered | ATK's top stainless pick didn't warp; some other clad models did |
About warping
Every source agrees on one thing: any sheet pan can warp. America's Test Kitchen explains why. The metal expands as it heats, and when cooler food lands on a hot pan, the spots under the food contract while the rest stays expanded, which twists the sheet. It happens most when a pan is preheated empty at high heat, as for roasting vegetables. In most cases the pan flattens again as it cools. Rolled or reinforced rims help. Nordic Ware uses encapsulated galvanized steel rims, and USA Pan uses steel wire in most rims plus a fluted bottom.
For cookies, which bake at moderate heat on a cool pan, warping is rarely the deciding factor. It matters more if you also roast at 425°F and up.
The picks
Best for most bakers: Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet (43100)
Bare aluminum, 1.6 lb, 1-inch rim, with encapsulated galvanized steel rims (Nordic Ware). Nordic Ware lists interior dimensions of 17.1 by 12.1 by 1 inches. It's America's Test Kitchen's winner, which found that everything cooked "appropriately and evenly" and called it sturdy and warp-resistant. Bon Appétit also picked it as best overall, noting it heats quickly and evenly and stays flat longer than competitors, though it will eventually warp. Wirecutter's caveats: food sticks unless you grease or line the pan, and it will darken with baked-on oil, which doesn't affect performance. Nordic Ware sells it singly and in multi-packs; for cookie season, two pans let one cool while the other bakes.
Our link goes to Nordic Ware's two-pack of Naturals half sheets (model 43105); the single-pan listing had no featured offer on Amazon when we checked.
Check current price on AmazonBest for easy release: USA Pan Half Sheet, nonstick (1050HS-1)
Aluminized steel with USA Pan's Americoat silicone release coating, which the company says is free of PTFE, PFOA and BPA. USA Pan lists a baking surface of 17.25 by 12.25 by 1 inches and a fluted (ridged) bottom meant to improve airflow and stiffness. The company's own care rules: don't exceed 450°F, hand wash, skip cooking spray, and use only silicone, nylon or wooden utensils. In The Spruce Eats' testing, cookies baked evenly and released with no sticking, but the pan warped while roasting at 425°F before returning to shape when it cooled. Prudent Reviews saw a corner buckle in an empty 450°F test. Good fit if you mostly bake cookies and hate scrubbing; less ideal for high-heat roasting.
Check current price on AmazonFor acidic roasting: a clad stainless-steel half sheet
America's Test Kitchen's stainless pick is the Williams Sonoma Thermo-Clad Stainless-Steel Ovenware Half Sheet, which comes with a matching rack. ATK found clad stainless cooked about as well as aluminum, browned a little faster, and weighed more than twice as much. ATK also found stainless pans cost far more than aluminum. We don't link this one, because it's sold by Williams Sonoma rather than on Amazon. For cookies alone, ATK's view is that aluminum remains the better choice for most home cooks.
Two add-ons worth having
A wire cooling rack sized for a half sheet
America's Test Kitchen recommends pairing a half sheet with a wire rack. It's their go-to setup for roasting and broiling, and it doubles as the place cookies cool. Check that the rack's outside dimensions fit inside your pan; ATK found that non-standard pans often need the maker's own rack. ATK's current favorite half-sheet rack is the Checkered Chef Cooling Rack (stainless steel, which ATK lists as broiler- and dishwasher-safe); ATK notes it has a little more wiggle room in the pan than other models. On Amazon it's sold as a two-pack in the 17 x 11 3/4 inch half-sheet size.
Check current price on AmazonA snap-on lid: Nordic Ware Half Sheet Cover
America's Test Kitchen tested Nordic Ware's plastic covers and recommends them. They snap on securely, cut down on plastic wrap and foil, and are sturdy enough to stack other things on in the fridge. Useful for carrying a pan of cookies to a swap. ATK also notes the half-sheet lid fits Nordic Ware's deeper Big Batch pan.
Our link goes to Nordic Ware's set of two Naturals half sheets with this lid; the lid-only listing had no featured offer on Amazon when we checked.
Check current price on AmazonCare tips that keep a pan working
- Hand wash aluminum. ATK says dishwasher detergent reacts with bare aluminum and can permanently discolor it.
- Don't worry about darkening. ATK says a dull, darker aluminum sheet isn't a bad thing.
- For stubborn stains on bare aluminum, Wirecutter suggests a baking-soda-and-water paste, a few minutes' wait, then a scouring pad. It leaves fine scratches but doesn't affect performance.
- Line pans for cookies. Parchment or a silicone mat solves sticking on bare aluminum, and USA Pan recommends a mat, foil or parchment for fatty foods to protect its coating.
- Avoid preheating an empty pan at very high heat if warping bothers you; ATK says that's when warping is most likely.
Sources
- America's Test Kitchen: The best rimmed baking sheets
- America's Test Kitchen: The best wire racks
- Bon Appétit: The best baking sheets
- Wirecutter: Why we love Nordic Ware baking sheets
- The Spruce Eats: The best half sheet pans
- Prudent Reviews: Nordic Ware vs. USA Pan
- Nordic Ware: Naturals Baker's Half Sheet (product page)
- USA Pan: Half Sheet Pan, nonstick (product page)
- USA Pan: Use and care FAQ